MBA value in the US and Europe

I’ve often wondered why there is such a difference between how MBAs are viewed in Europe and the US. It may be obvious, but here’s my take – it’s cultural, and the reason why lies in cheap ads.

Here’s a sign I caught while waiting in line at a currency exchange:

Do you see that? The chap who started this little business put his name on the bottom. Keith Berkson is darn proud of being on that sign. More: if you’ve ever ridden a bus in the states, you’ll probably have noticed an LCD screen at the front pumping out cheap ads, and they’re full of these big chested characters wearing suits and big collars pointing at the screen to emphasise how much THIS product could save YOU.

That simply doesn’t happen in the UK. Our entrepreneurs, successful as they are, are almost embarrassed to be in that position. Our cheap ads consist of a cheesy voiceover, and a video of someone hammering their thumb before the Dremel Multitool comes out and saves the day.

Academically, the MBA is basically a big set of instructions in how to run a business properly. In a culture that values business so highly, it’s no surprise the MBA is also held in high regard here.







3 responses to “MBA value in the US and Europe”

  1. Another funny and astute observation about trans-Atlantic differences, Shahid. It’s the second of your posts I’ve added to my weekly Top 5. Thanks!

  2. dan

    But what about Carol Vorderman? She’s more than happy to stick her chest out on any debt-busting home-owner loan ad…

  3. J. Edgar

    “Academically, the MBA is basically a big set of instructions in how to run a business properly” It’s a nice thought, but I think the US version is mostly more like a branding machine that turns otherwise imaginative human beings into the “good employee.” Sure, you’ll get a nice job through the Alum network, and get to wear the same suits, same ties, same tassled loafers, but will you be you?

    It is also an endowment boomerang. Just wait and see how much you get harrassed for endowments by your Alum association and other Uni staff. There will be nowhere to hide.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *